Citrus Rootstock: Troyer Citrange

What do you want to know?
חץ

Hebrew: טְרוֹיֵיר, troyer
Parentage: Trifoliate orange x sweet orange
Scientific name: Citrus × insitorum
Country of origin: USA

Advantages: Resistant to tristeza (virus that attacks the tree) and phytophthora fungus (which attacks the root collar).

Disadvantages: Sensitivity to saline and calcareous soils, as well as to soils with poor drainage. Most varieties grafted onto this rootstock will show incompatibility after 15 years, which will manifest in branch dieback and later in tree death.

Kilei ilan (grafting mixed species): This rootstock is compatible with all types of citruses.

According to halachah, it is permissible to graft orange and clementine onto this rootstock.

 

Explanation

According to the laws of kilayim, there must be similarity between two plants in at least one of the  following three criteria to classify them as the same species:

  • Fruit shape
  • Leaf shape
  • Fruit taste

If the fruit taste differs significantly between the two species, they are considered kilayim even if the other two criteria were met. For citrus, there is a significant dispute among the Acharonim on how to address the differences among the various species. Chazon Ish maintains that “all citrus species are one,” but in any case of doubt, grafting and planting should be performed by a non-Jew. Rabbi Kook, however, views oranges as an entirely different species from grapefruits and thus regards the two as distinct species.

From a halachic perspective, we classify the citruses into three different families. Grafts are permitted within each family only:

  1. Citron (etrog) and lemon group
  2. Pomelo and grapefruit group
  3. Orange group, which is currently the main group among the various citrus species, includes oranges and mandarins (clementine).

 

Orlah (waiting three years for fruit): While technically a fruit tree, the orlah prohibition applies only to the use of the fruit, not of the branches.